Category: Research

  • AERC research impact: twelve studies and what they changed

    AERC research impact: twelve studies and what they changed

    In short: a 2016 independent study of AERC research impact found that the AERC and its successor awarded more than £24 million (inflation-adjusted) to nearly 900 projects between 1982 and 2014. The studies with the clearest legacy tested brief advice in GP surgeries, emergency departments and pharmacies, evaluated family programmes, and produced evidence on alcohol marketing and licensing that reached Parliament, NICE and the WHO.

    It is easy to list what a funder paid for. It is harder to show what changed as a result. In 2015 Alcohol Research UK, the AERC’s successor, commissioned an independent team led by Professor Richard Velleman of the University of Bath, with Lorna Templeton, Dr Anthony Hewitt and Gill Velleman, to trace the impact of every award made since 1982. Their report, Researching alcohol harm: 30 years of impact, was published in March 2016. This page summarises its case studies, in date order within each theme. Awards up to 2011 were made by the AERC itself; later ones by Alcohol Research UK.

    The scale, by the numbers

    Measure, 1982–2014Figure
    Total awarded (inflation-adjusted)More than £24 million
    Projects, fellowships and studentshipsNearly 900
    Main award recipientsOver 1,000 people
    Spent in England£15.0 million
    Spent in Scotland£5.3 million
    Spent in Wales£1.5 million
    Spent in Northern Ireland£740,000
    Screening and brief intervention projectsAlmost £2.4 million
    Children and families affected by alcoholOver £1 million

    Awards ranged from six-figure research projects to grants of under £100 to help a student present at a conference. For the Council’s own accounts and grant schemes, see What was the AERC?

    A GP surgery waiting room with empty chairs and a notice board
    Brief advice in general practice was the Council’s first big theme. Illustration.

    Brief advice in health settings

    This is the theme where the line from grant to national practice is clearest.

    1. 1984, GP brief advice (WHO multinational study). Part of a World Health Organization study of low-cost interventions for problem drinkers. Professor Paul Wallace called it “a ground-breaking trial of screening and brief interventions for risky drinkers in general practice”. A later AERC grant prepared the Medical Research Council-funded Down Your Drink trial of online brief intervention.
    2. 1995, getting GPs to use it. Professors Brian McAvoy, Eileen Kaner and Nick Heather ran a randomised trial, with the WHO, of ways to encourage GPs to take up early intervention, identifying the most useful and cost-effective approaches.
    3. 1996, emergency departments. Professor Jonathan Shepherd evaluated brief intervention in A&E. The findings prompted a Royal College of Surgeons statement on brief advice, informed the Department of Health’s SIPS trials and led, with the Welsh Government, to the Have a Word training programme in Wales, which the report says has trained 11,000 health and other professionals to give brief advice.
    4. 2001, alcohol health workers. Professor Mike Crawford’s trial compared referral to an Alcohol Health Worker with information alone for A&E patients. It produced five peer-reviewed papers, including a highly cited one in The Lancet, and was cited in the 2004 public health White Paper Choosing Health and a 2008 National Audit Office report.
    5. 2006, community pharmacists. Professor Derek Stewart’s team ran what the report calls the first study of pharmacists delivering alcohol brief interventions. It later fed a Scottish Government review of pharmacy’s role.
    6. 2012, measuring change. Dr Bob Patton’s survey of English emergency units found that screening, advice and access to specialist alcohol nurses had all increased significantly since a 2006 survey.

    Many of the final reports behind this work are listed in the reader’s guide to the final reports.

    A community pharmacy counter with shelves of boxed medicines
    The first study of pharmacists giving alcohol advice was funded in 2006. Illustration.

    Training the people who help

    In 1987 an AERC grant to Alcohol Concern set up the Volunteer Alcohol Counsellors Training Scheme (VACTS), which created syllabuses, competency standards and accreditation for volunteer counsellors in England and Wales. Eric Appleby, Alcohol Concern’s former chief executive, says VACTS “directly led to” the Drug and Alcohol National Occupational Standards (DANOS). In 2009 a grant established the Alcohol Academy, which trained local alcohol leads and commissioners across England and ran the Alcohol Policy UK blog.

    A straight glass and a curved glass of pale lager side by side on a bar
    Drinkers took 60% longer to finish from a straight glass in the 2009 Bristol study. Illustration.

    Did the research reach policy on marketing and licensing?

    Yes, in at least three documented cases.

    • Advertising review (funded 2006, published 2009). Professors Lesley Smith and David Foxcroft reviewed seven studies following more than 13,000 young people aged 10 to 26. All seven found significant effects of advertising exposure on when young people start drinking and how much they drink. The review was cited in OECD and WHO reports.
    • Industry documents (2009). Professor Gerard Hastings analysed internal marketing documents obtained by the House of Commons Health Select Committee, under the title “They’ll drink bucket loads of the stuff”. He concluded that self-regulatory codes were not protecting young people.
    • Scottish licensing (2011). Alcohol Focus Scotland evaluated Scotland’s 2005 decision to make public health a licensing objective. The project produced a toolkit for licensing teams and a UK network on licensing and public health, co-chaired by Public Health England.

    Drinking behaviour and culture

    In the late 1990s the Council supported UK participation in two international surveys through the Alcohol Health Research Centre and Professor Moira Plant: ESPAD, the European school survey of young people’s drinking and smoking run every four years from 1995, and GENACIS, a 40-country study of gender and alcohol whose early results gave the first sign of a real rise in young women’s drinking.

    The most quoted single result came from Bristol in 2009. Angela Attwood and colleagues found that social drinkers were 60% slower to finish a drink from a straight glass than from a curved one. It was a Small Grant project, yet it drew wide media interest, and the Behavioural Insights Team at the Department of Health took the idea further.

    From 2012 Professor Mark Bellis’s team at Liverpool John Moores University surveyed more than 7,000 people in England on the “alcohol harm paradox”: why poorer communities suffer more alcohol harm despite drinking similar amounts. Asking about special occasions uncovered around an extra bottle of wine per person compared with standard surveys.

    A family kitchen table with schoolbooks and mugs
    Family programmes such as Strengthening Families were evaluated with AERC money. Illustration.

    Families, children and schools

    In 2004 AERC-funded projects piloted and evaluated the American Strengthening Families Programme. Lindsey Coombes describes it as the first UK evaluation of the 10–14 version, and says that without it commissioners would probably not have chosen the programme. A 2014 study by Professor Liz Gilchrist and colleagues found that police records linked two-thirds of domestic incidents to at least one partner drinking.

    Not every result was positive, and the report says so. A 2013 randomised trial of In:tuition, a Drinkaware schools programme for 10 to 13-year-olds, found no evidence of impact compared with existing lessons, and Drinkaware stopped rolling it out. Alcohol Research UK oversaw that trial as a “firewall” between the evaluators and the programme’s developer.

    A council chamber set out for a licensing committee hearing
    Scotland’s public health licensing objective was evaluated in 2011. Illustration.

    How to read AERC research impact claims

    The Alcohol Research UK impact study was commissioned by the funder, so it describes successes in the funder’s terms, though it was carried out by an independent team and includes a null result. Treat it as a guide to which studies mattered, then read the original papers. Where a case study cites a Lancet paper, a White Paper or a NICE recommendation, those documents are the stronger evidence. To trace an original report, use How to find and cite an old AERC report.

    Key takeaways

    • A 2016 independent impact study found that the AERC and its successor awarded more than £24 million (inflation-adjusted) to nearly 900 projects between 1982 and 2014.
    • The clearest AERC research impact came from studies of brief advice in GP surgeries, emergency departments and pharmacies.
    • AERC-funded work also evaluated family programmes and trained the professionals who deliver help.
    • Evidence on alcohol marketing and licensing reached Parliament, NICE and the WHO.

    Common questions

    What was the AERC’s most influential research?

    On the impact study’s evidence, the brief intervention trials: the 1984 GP study, the 1996 A&E study and the 2001 alcohol health worker trial, which fed into the SIPS programme, Have a Word and national guidance.

    Who carried out the impact study?

    An independent team led by Professor Richard Velleman, Emeritus Professor at the University of Bath, with Lorna Templeton, Dr Anthony Hewitt and Gill Velleman. The report was published by Alcohol Research UK in March 2016.

    Did the AERC fund the glass-shape study?

    Yes. The impact study records a 2009 Small Grant to Angela Attwood and colleagues at the University of Bristol, which found people drank 60% more slowly from a straight glass than a curved one.

    Did any funded programme fail?

    Yes. The 2013 trial of the In:tuition schools programme found no evidence of impact, and dissemination was stopped. Publishing null results is part of what made the funder credible.

    Where does this research continue today?

    With Alcohol Change UK, formed when Alcohol Research UK merged with Alcohol Concern in 2017. See Where the AERC’s work lives now.

    How we put this together: the figures and study outcomes come from the 2016 independent impact study commissioned by Alcohol Research UK. Every source is listed below.

    Sources

  • AERC final reports: a reader’s guide by theme

    AERC final reports: a reader’s guide by theme

    In short: every AERC-funded project ended with a final report, usually a PDF with a short executive summary. The old aerc.org.uk links no longer work, but many reports are published by Alcohol Change UK. This guide groups a selection of AERC final reports by theme, says what each study asked and links to where it can be read today.

    Each project funded by the Alcohol Education and Research Council ended with a final report. On the old website these sat at addresses such as /documents/pdfs/finalReports/AERC_FinalReport_0039.pdf. Those links stopped working when the site closed in 2011, but many of the reports are published by Alcohol Change UK, each marked as funded or written by “our predecessor organisation, the Alcohol Education Research Council.”

    Below is a selection grouped by theme. Each entry says what the study set out to do and links to its publication page, where the full report and summary can be downloaded. Dates are those shown on the publication pages. For how the Council chose what to fund, see What was the AERC?

    Screening and brief interventions

    A large share of AERC funding went into testing short, structured conversations about drinking in ordinary health and work settings. The practical question for the NHS was whether busy staff could ask about alcohol and offer brief advice without specialist training. Several of these studies fed directly into later national programmes, as described in What AERC research changed.

    A GP consulting room with two chairs and a desk, morning light
    Screening and brief advice in primary care was a core AERC theme. Illustration.

    Young people and drinking

    Young people’s drinking was a constant concern of the 2000s, and the Council funded work on where and why teenagers drank, how the media framed it and what schools could do.

    The Council’s 2007–08 annual report lists more projects in the same vein that were funded that year, including studies of alcohol in UK university sport (Northumbria University), student drinking at the University of Northampton, an evaluation of the Kids, Adults Together family forum programme at Cardiff University, and a Community Alcohol Partnership in Cambridgeshire working on underage drinking.

    Communities and the night-time economy

    The same 2007–08 report describes the United Kingdom Community Alcohol Prevention Project (UKCAPP), a major Council-funded development based in Cardiff, Birmingham and Glasgow. Its community action programmes combined bar-staff training, police work to prevent public disorder and community mobilisation, and it was evaluated by the Bath Mental Health R&D Unit. Projects like this are less likely to have a single tidy final report online, so the annual reports are the best starting point for tracing them.

    A city street corner at dusk with shuttered shops
    Studies of young people’s street drinking looked at marketing and subculture. Illustration.

    Drinking cultures and history

    A blood pressure monitor and notebook on a clinic table
    Several reports examined drinking and physical health. Illustration.

    Health effects and safer levels

    A quiet counselling room with two armchairs and a low table
    Treatment research included measuring how therapy was delivered. Illustration.

    Treatment research

    How should you read AERC final reports today?

    Most of these studies are between fifteen and twenty-five years old. They are valuable for the history of UK alcohol policy and for the methods they tested, but guidance has moved on. The UK Chief Medical Officers’ low-risk drinking guidelines were revised in 2016, for example, so a 2002 study of “optimal” consumption is a record of research at the time rather than current advice.

    Three habits help:

    1. Read the executive summary first. AERC reports were written for practitioners as well as academics, and the summary usually states the question, the sample and the main finding on one page.
    2. Check the design. Many AERC grants paid for pilots and feasibility studies. A feasibility study tells you whether a trial could be run, not whether the intervention works.
    3. Look for the follow-on. If a pilot mattered, a larger study or a journal paper usually followed. Search the authors’ names and the topic to find it.
    Printed research report pages with a highlighter and reading glasses on a desk
    Most final reports open with a short executive summary. Illustration.

    Old report numbers

    The old site numbered reports in a series, such as AERC_FinalReport_0035 or 0039. Some of those files are still available under the same names on Alcohol Change UK’s file store, for example AERC_FinalReport_0035.pdf. If you have an old report number, try the same file name at that address before searching by title. The step-by-step method is in How to find and cite an old AERC report.

    Key takeaways

    • Every AERC-funded project ended with a final report, usually a PDF with a short executive summary.
    • The old aerc.org.uk links no longer work, but many AERC final reports are published by Alcohol Change UK.
    • The reports cluster around a few themes: brief interventions, young people, communities and the night-time economy, drinking cultures, health effects and treatment.
    • Read older reports for their methods and context, and check newer evidence before relying on their findings.

    Common questions

    Are all AERC final reports online?

    No. Many are on Alcohol Change UK’s publication pages, but not every project produced a public report and some survive only as journal papers or in the Council’s archive at the Wellcome Collection.

    Who owns the copyright in AERC reports?

    Usually the authors or their institutions, with the funder credited. Alcohol Change UK publishes many as the successor organisation. Check the report itself before reproducing material.

    What was an “Alcohol Insight”?

    A short plain-English summary that every AERC grant holder had to produce, according to the Council’s 2010–11 annual report. They were designed to get findings to practitioners quickly.

    Can I still apply to the AERC for a grant?

    No. The Council closed in 2011. Its grant-making passed to Alcohol Research UK and then to Alcohol Change UK, which sets its own funding priorities.

    How we put this together: the studies are drawn from the Council’s annual reports and from copies published by Alcohol Change UK, and the links point to versions that can be read today. Every source is listed below.

    Sources